Back when Joss Whedon was writing Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Firefly and Dollhouse, he was repeatedly asked questions about why he wrote such strong female characters. His answer, finally, was given in a speech he presented on equality, when he simply stated "Because you're still asking me this question."*
George R.R. Martin, author of the Game of Thrones books, was asked where his inspiration for complex, well-written female characters came from, and he responded that he "always considered women to be people."**
Most feminists and female readers know about the concept of the Bechdel test, developed by Allison Bechdel to determine whether a work gives a fair or even remotely non-sexist depiction of women. The test has three parts: (1) Does this work include at least two female characters?; (2) Do these characters talk to one another?; (3) Is the conversation about something other than men? If you can successfully answer "yes" to all three of those questions, congratulations, there is a chance you have written a remotely non-sexist piece.
However, Kelly Sue Deconnick, a writer and artist for Marvel comics, stated that the Bechdel Test may be expecting too much from us, and has proposed a test wherein "if you can take out a female character and replace her with a sexy lamp, you're a hack."*** My question, then, is when a large number of female characters fail both Bechdel's test and are replacable by a sexy lamp, why are we asking those few writers who write women who actually resemble people why they write them that way?
What does it say about the status quo for female characters when the noteworthy and novel thing is that they're written in three dimensions instead of just as a plot device?
I've often advocated for the need for strong female role models, and those are often hard to find in the real world. But it's worrisome that they are nearly as scarce in the world of fantasy and fiction, and that those writers who create them are often questioned or criticized.
Isn't it time that, instead, we start asking, "I've noticed you've written a hollow shell of a human being and slapped a pair of breasts on her. Why did you do that?" instead?
Curiously Yours,
Rachel Leigh
*http://www.americanrhetoric.com/speeches/josswhedonequalitynow.htm
**http://hbowatch.com/20-minute-interview-with-george-r-r-martin/
***http://www.ign.com/articles/2013/06/20/kelly-sue-deconnick-talks-captain-marvel-pretty-deadly-and-the-sexy-lamp-test
Showing posts with label culture. Show all posts
Showing posts with label culture. Show all posts
Thursday, July 11, 2013
Monday, June 17, 2013
On Dumb Culture
Now, I'm generally not a fan of calling attention to people with rocks for brains, mostly because I think stupid people get too much attention anyway. However, in the aftermath of a stunningly incoherent speech about women, education, men's inherent leadership role, and job creation from Miss Utah in the Miss Universe pageant and the incredibly disheartening news that Sarah Palin will be entering the network news circuit as a political commentator (admittedly on Fox News, but that's still more viewers than she should be getting), I need to speak up.
I am all for female role models. We definitely need more of them.
But, for the love of all that is good in this world and for the sake of creating a better future for the next few generations of girls, can we please stop treating ignorant, uneducated women as something endearing or desirable?
We have a culture that says that women are bad at math and science, despite repeated studies that show that the gap in performance occurs over time, as girls LEARN they aren't supposed to be good at math and science. We discourage women from entering leadership roles, and those who do are often met with sexism and criticism of their mental and emotional capabilities in their role. And, despite the continued push for empowering female education, we still hear things like "My boyfriend thinks I'm too smart for him" (vlogbrothers video) or "'If smart guys like dumb girls and dumb guys like dumb girls, what do smart girls get?' 'Cats, mostly'" (Modern Family).
Glamourizing and promoting the idea that it's "cute" for a woman to be ditzy or ignorant makes intelligent girls feel like their intelligence is a hindrance -- something to be ashamed of and hidden if they ever want to be loved or taken seriously. But what good does it do for society to teach half the population that, if they're good at something, they should try and hide it?
Ignorance isn't cute. It isn't funny. It's sad, it's an insult to our education system, and it's really bad for the way girls see themselves.
Angrily yours,
Rachel Leigh
I am all for female role models. We definitely need more of them.
But, for the love of all that is good in this world and for the sake of creating a better future for the next few generations of girls, can we please stop treating ignorant, uneducated women as something endearing or desirable?
We have a culture that says that women are bad at math and science, despite repeated studies that show that the gap in performance occurs over time, as girls LEARN they aren't supposed to be good at math and science. We discourage women from entering leadership roles, and those who do are often met with sexism and criticism of their mental and emotional capabilities in their role. And, despite the continued push for empowering female education, we still hear things like "My boyfriend thinks I'm too smart for him" (vlogbrothers video) or "'If smart guys like dumb girls and dumb guys like dumb girls, what do smart girls get?' 'Cats, mostly'" (Modern Family).
Glamourizing and promoting the idea that it's "cute" for a woman to be ditzy or ignorant makes intelligent girls feel like their intelligence is a hindrance -- something to be ashamed of and hidden if they ever want to be loved or taken seriously. But what good does it do for society to teach half the population that, if they're good at something, they should try and hide it?
Ignorance isn't cute. It isn't funny. It's sad, it's an insult to our education system, and it's really bad for the way girls see themselves.
Angrily yours,
Rachel Leigh
Sunday, December 2, 2012
On the Season
I have been terrible about posting this past month. I'm sorry, my darling readers. Between Prague, papers, exams, classes, Thanksgiving, and other such craziness, there just hasn't been a lot of time for it. Not an excuse, I know.
Happy December! I had my first (and likely only) traditional Danish Julefrokost (Christmas lunch) yesterday with the other DIS students in my kollegium and our Danish SRA. Why they call it "lunch" when it starts at like 7 pm is beyond me. But the food was delicious and the boys did a great job (since the girls took care of Thanksgiving). They brought a table out into the hallway and it was adorable.
I can't really talk about Julefrokost without talking about alcohol. Little-known fact - the Danes drink pretty heavily. Well, actually, if you read Scandinavia and the World (it's a comic), it's actually apparently a very well-known fact in Scandinavia. But I had no idea before I came to this country. Anyway, Christmas lunch involves Danish snaps and akvavit, both of which are really strong, and you're drinking all through the meal. In a country where they release a Christmas and Easter specialty beer, I think it might be safe to say that the only thing the Danes love more than getting cozy with family and friends is an excuse to party.
Friday night my Danish class went to see Tornerose (Sleeping Beauty) at the Royal Theatre, which was absolutely wonderful. It's hard to wrap my mind around the fact that I'm only here for two more weeks. I still need to go see the Christmas lights at Tivoli. And survive finals week.
Tis the season,
Rachel Leigh
Happy December! I had my first (and likely only) traditional Danish Julefrokost (Christmas lunch) yesterday with the other DIS students in my kollegium and our Danish SRA. Why they call it "lunch" when it starts at like 7 pm is beyond me. But the food was delicious and the boys did a great job (since the girls took care of Thanksgiving). They brought a table out into the hallway and it was adorable.
I can't really talk about Julefrokost without talking about alcohol. Little-known fact - the Danes drink pretty heavily. Well, actually, if you read Scandinavia and the World (it's a comic), it's actually apparently a very well-known fact in Scandinavia. But I had no idea before I came to this country. Anyway, Christmas lunch involves Danish snaps and akvavit, both of which are really strong, and you're drinking all through the meal. In a country where they release a Christmas and Easter specialty beer, I think it might be safe to say that the only thing the Danes love more than getting cozy with family and friends is an excuse to party.
Friday night my Danish class went to see Tornerose (Sleeping Beauty) at the Royal Theatre, which was absolutely wonderful. It's hard to wrap my mind around the fact that I'm only here for two more weeks. I still need to go see the Christmas lights at Tivoli. And survive finals week.
Tis the season,
Rachel Leigh
Thursday, November 1, 2012
On "Teach Me How to Hygge"
As it's getting into those infamous dark, cold Danish winter months (Happy November, by the way), and I've been here for two and a half months now, I think it's time. And maybe also because of a shirt idea that I saw. It's time, of course, to talk about hygge.
Hygge - it's a noun, it's a verb, it's an adjective. You can hygge yourself or be hyggelig with friends. Say it with me: "hygge." Okay, so, because of the absurd number of Danish vowel sounds, let me help you out "Hoo-ga"...except force that first syllable out like you're also trying to say a y or an e at the same time.
My understanding isn't perfect, as I'm relatively certain it couldn't be if you didn't grow up in these Nordic winters, but I understand enough at this point to talk about it a bit. And it's such a huge aspect of Danish culture that I would be doing my darling readers a disservice to not talk about it at least a little bit.
Hygge roughly translates to "cozy" in English, and most Northern European cultures have some versions of the same sort of spirit. It's originally a Norwegian word, though the Norwegian version is more about personal well-being. And apparently in German, the concept of Gemütlichkeit is pretty similar.
From what I can tell, hygge developed mostly as a reaction to the cold, dark winters. The basic idea is to take comfort in being home or with close friends. A hyggelig cafe is one with blankets and big comfy chairs. And candles. You cannot have hygge without candles. One of the Danes that I live with explained that "Staying in with your grandma, drinking tea and watching old movies...that's hygge." A nice piece of wienerbrød (the Danish word for a danish) and a hot cup of coffee as you curl up with friends - that's hygge. The night I spent watching Disaster Preppers with my roommate from UR and the Danes who live on her hall -- okay, probably not hyggelig, but close.
It's all about being warm and happy with the people and things you love as a way to fight off the impending Seasonal Affective Disorder, and it is fundamentally Danish. And I think that's pretty damn cool.
Gettin' hyggelig with it,
Rachel Leigh
Hygge - it's a noun, it's a verb, it's an adjective. You can hygge yourself or be hyggelig with friends. Say it with me: "hygge." Okay, so, because of the absurd number of Danish vowel sounds, let me help you out "Hoo-ga"...except force that first syllable out like you're also trying to say a y or an e at the same time.
My understanding isn't perfect, as I'm relatively certain it couldn't be if you didn't grow up in these Nordic winters, but I understand enough at this point to talk about it a bit. And it's such a huge aspect of Danish culture that I would be doing my darling readers a disservice to not talk about it at least a little bit.
Hygge roughly translates to "cozy" in English, and most Northern European cultures have some versions of the same sort of spirit. It's originally a Norwegian word, though the Norwegian version is more about personal well-being. And apparently in German, the concept of Gemütlichkeit is pretty similar.
From what I can tell, hygge developed mostly as a reaction to the cold, dark winters. The basic idea is to take comfort in being home or with close friends. A hyggelig cafe is one with blankets and big comfy chairs. And candles. You cannot have hygge without candles. One of the Danes that I live with explained that "Staying in with your grandma, drinking tea and watching old movies...that's hygge." A nice piece of wienerbrød (the Danish word for a danish) and a hot cup of coffee as you curl up with friends - that's hygge. The night I spent watching Disaster Preppers with my roommate from UR and the Danes who live on her hall -- okay, probably not hyggelig, but close.
It's all about being warm and happy with the people and things you love as a way to fight off the impending Seasonal Affective Disorder, and it is fundamentally Danish. And I think that's pretty damn cool.
Gettin' hyggelig with it,
Rachel Leigh
On Lessons I Learned From TV
TV taught me how to feel, now real life has no appeal.
Marina and the Diamonds has it right. (Side note: Way to be real world for totally not recognizing my Halloween costume.) I have spent way too much of my life watching television and feeling all the feels. But thinking back on it I've realized I've learned some interesting lessons.
Things TV Taught Me:
- It's Never Lupus. Except when it is. Any House fan out there probably knows this. It's like the fundamental rule of House. I think the real takeaways from this, though, were that a) it's never as bad as it could be and b) no trope is safe from subversion. Because it's never lupus. Except for that one episode where it was totally lupus.
- Don't Mess With the Girl Who Can Kill You With Her Brain. River Tam is smarter than you. She's a better fighter than you. Also, she can kill you with her brain. This crazy lady from Firefly is probably the biggest reason to never break the heart of a smart and emotionally unstable girl. She will find you. She will kill you.
- When You're Sad You Should Stop Being Sad and Be Awesome Instead. Okay, so it's not usually that simple. But I have to give Barney Stinson some credit for this one... Sometimes the best way to get past being sad is to just pretend that you're not sad, force yourself to go do something fun, and let the fun make you actually not-sad. Be awesome instead. Also, a more important lesson from HIMYM: more people should suit up. You look really classy, and I love that. Also NPH is a god.
- Even If You're Completely Nuts, Good Friends Will Love You Anyway. Okay, so this isn't based off of a quote, but seriously. Sheldon Cooper. Gregory House. Donna Noble. Real friends love you for who you are, even if that means you are an absolute psycho sometimes.
- Fictional Characters Are Better At Their Jobs Than Real People. Jed Bartlet. That is all.
- And finally, it doesn't matter if it's non-canon, inappropriate, incest, against their sexual orientation, squicky, or if it involves inanimate objects, bending of fictional universes, or time travel. Somebody Out There Ships It.
I enjoyed this post, and while I was writing it, I started thinking of examples from books and movies, so there is a decent chance there will be future lists based around books and movies.
Your Favorite Couch-Potato,
Rachel Leigh
Monday, July 9, 2012
On Graffiti and the DB of the Day
Here's the thing: I love graffiti. I think a well-executed tag in the right place adds one of the coolest possible touches to an urban landscape. Aside from that, there are very few things in the world that I find as cool as spray paint.
But there's a difference between a really cool, artistically-executed signature tag on an abandoned building, and some of the crap I've seen in the last couple days. I live in a relatively small town, not particularly known for its crime, and I'll admit, the first time I saw what looked like a non-sensical tagline spray-painted on a billboard that I didn't even like anyway, I laughed.
But seeing the same tagline spray-painted on the side of a small business that had just been opened (and had the building re-done in the process)? That just makes me angry. A good tagger is an artist -- Banksy is a legend who uses spray-paint as a medium to convey intense messages about politics and society in creative and highly-public way. Someone who thinks its cool to paint a penis on the side of a mailbox or their pseudo-intellectual "tagger name" on the side of a building is nothing more than an asshole.
So today's DBotD Award goes to -- that guy. You know who you are. And you're just a dick.
Angrily yours,
Rachel Leigh
But there's a difference between a really cool, artistically-executed signature tag on an abandoned building, and some of the crap I've seen in the last couple days. I live in a relatively small town, not particularly known for its crime, and I'll admit, the first time I saw what looked like a non-sensical tagline spray-painted on a billboard that I didn't even like anyway, I laughed.
But seeing the same tagline spray-painted on the side of a small business that had just been opened (and had the building re-done in the process)? That just makes me angry. A good tagger is an artist -- Banksy is a legend who uses spray-paint as a medium to convey intense messages about politics and society in creative and highly-public way. Someone who thinks its cool to paint a penis on the side of a mailbox or their pseudo-intellectual "tagger name" on the side of a building is nothing more than an asshole.
So today's DBotD Award goes to -- that guy. You know who you are. And you're just a dick.
Angrily yours,
Rachel Leigh
Wednesday, April 18, 2012
On The Things I Assume About You Based on Where You Study
You know that scene in Mean Girls when Janice and Damien are explaining the layout of the cafeteria to Cady, going around and pointing out all of the stereotypes and social groups? Of course you do, because it's one of the greatest scenes in a movie that will define our generation. My school is kind of like that. And while I could go on for days about the stereotypes about the layout of our dining hall, I have something else to vent about.
With finals right around the corner and the entire population of the school (except the seniors who are so close to graduating that you can physically feel the number of f*cks they do not give) is going to start marking territory around Boatwright like some possessive, tiny-bladdered puppy, it seemed like the right time to do this. I give you: "Partially-Unfounded Assumptions I Make About You Based on Where You Study"
Finally,
Rachel Leigh
With finals right around the corner and the entire population of the school (except the seniors who are so close to graduating that you can physically feel the number of f*cks they do not give) is going to start marking territory around Boatwright like some possessive, tiny-bladdered puppy, it seemed like the right time to do this. I give you: "Partially-Unfounded Assumptions I Make About You Based on Where You Study"
- Boatwright (the Library): As a general rule, you're checking Facebook more than your textbook and probably using 8:15 and potty breaks as just another excuse to procrastinate. Then again, so are the rest of us. But there's more to it than that.
- B2: Aww...the group study area. Couples that want to be obnoxiously coupley in the not-so-private privacy of the bottom level, a couple awkward study rooms, and the bathroom that people use when they really need to poop and don't want to be around other people.
- B1: Fratstars and the sorority biddies who love them (also known as the B-school in exile). Also, the socially awkward people who actually WANT to sit and study on the silent floor. I assume you have no social skills, no friends, and a generally sad future ahead of you.
- First Floor
- Open Area: I get it. You're here with your sorority fam and you'll get on each other's cases to get work done after you finish catching up on the gossip you couldn't catch up on at chapter, fam dinner, and that time you got lunch like two hours ago.
- Quiet Section: Also known as the "We came here to get shit done" section of the library.
- Second Floor
- Open Area: Frat guys and loud Internationals. It's funny that you expected to get work done.
- Quiet Section: No really, who ARE you people? I'm pretty sure I've never seen you in my life, probably because you never leave this room, and PLEASE stop glaring at me for slamming the bathroom door. I can't help it that it's so dead silent in here that you could hear a fly land on a table.
- MRC: Don't even pretend you're doing anything other than checking Facebook and watching movies. I can see your computer screen.
- Gottwald (Science Building): I assume your life is sad, you probably haven't slept in anything other than that chair in the lobby in about a week, and I'm sincerely concerned about the last time you showered.
- The B-School: You couldn't even detach yourself from outside Dean's office door and dress like a college student rather than my 40 year old math professor long enough to leave the B-School to study somewhere else. You worry me.
- Your Dorm Room: You say "studying," I say "watching Netflix and ordering Jimmy Johns"
Finally,
Rachel Leigh
Monday, April 2, 2012
So I may have just left this discussion called "The Faces of Feminism," which was this talk about the definition of feminism and people's experiences with feminism in their everyday lives. And by "may have," I definitely mean "did." I almost feel like I need to be apologetic when I get serious on this blog, because it seems like most of my darling readers prefer when I'm just talking about something completely ridiculous. Honestly, those are more fun to write.
But anyway, I think what stood out to me the most was this idea that there are so many different personal definitions of feminism (and, as a result, so many different kinds of feminists), and that this really stems from the fact that the ways people come to identify as feminist are all actually pretty personal and unique journeys.
If you remember (which I wouldn't blame you if you didn't...some days I don't remember what I ate for breakfast (spoiler alert: I usually sleep through it)), I did a post way back when I started this blog about why I self-identify as a Democrat. I guess this is kind of my reasons for identifying as a feminist? We'll see.
I'm sure my story begins somewhere along the lines with my beliefs about sexual and domestic violence. The two for me are completely inseparable, and I think, to a large extent, that's really what shapes my personal views of feminism. It also doesn't help that I'm a philosophy minor and an absolute freak about ethical philosophy. I think my views on pretty much everything are inextricably tied to this idea that people are autonomous, unique, and incomprehensible, and that these characteristics alone make you deserving of being treated like a human being and no less than anyone else. I'm a feminist, honestly, because I think no one has a right to make anyone an object, for any reason.
I'm not even sure how to feel about the idea of the word "feminism." I think maybe it scares people off? Honestly, I would never deny being a feminist, but I more often identify as an ethicist than a feminist because, for me, it's not about gender, or race, or sexual orientation, or socioeconomic status, because those are all just (to some extent) arbitrary and artificial categories that are super-imposed over the larger issue and, honestly, cloud it a lot of the time. You have a right to your body, to your opinion, to earn fair compensation for your work, to speak and act freely, to love and be loved as you see fit not in virtue of how you identify but merely on the grounds that you're human, and that being human means that there are things about you which no one else can ever fully understand, control, or consume. It's not about being different...or even the same...it's about not attempting to categorize the things you can't ever fully understand, and not being able to give or deny rights to someone on the grounds of the things you don't understand.
adjfkldjfkljdklfj,
Rachel Leigh
But anyway, I think what stood out to me the most was this idea that there are so many different personal definitions of feminism (and, as a result, so many different kinds of feminists), and that this really stems from the fact that the ways people come to identify as feminist are all actually pretty personal and unique journeys.
If you remember (which I wouldn't blame you if you didn't...some days I don't remember what I ate for breakfast (spoiler alert: I usually sleep through it)), I did a post way back when I started this blog about why I self-identify as a Democrat. I guess this is kind of my reasons for identifying as a feminist? We'll see.
I'm sure my story begins somewhere along the lines with my beliefs about sexual and domestic violence. The two for me are completely inseparable, and I think, to a large extent, that's really what shapes my personal views of feminism. It also doesn't help that I'm a philosophy minor and an absolute freak about ethical philosophy. I think my views on pretty much everything are inextricably tied to this idea that people are autonomous, unique, and incomprehensible, and that these characteristics alone make you deserving of being treated like a human being and no less than anyone else. I'm a feminist, honestly, because I think no one has a right to make anyone an object, for any reason.
I'm not even sure how to feel about the idea of the word "feminism." I think maybe it scares people off? Honestly, I would never deny being a feminist, but I more often identify as an ethicist than a feminist because, for me, it's not about gender, or race, or sexual orientation, or socioeconomic status, because those are all just (to some extent) arbitrary and artificial categories that are super-imposed over the larger issue and, honestly, cloud it a lot of the time. You have a right to your body, to your opinion, to earn fair compensation for your work, to speak and act freely, to love and be loved as you see fit not in virtue of how you identify but merely on the grounds that you're human, and that being human means that there are things about you which no one else can ever fully understand, control, or consume. It's not about being different...or even the same...it's about not attempting to categorize the things you can't ever fully understand, and not being able to give or deny rights to someone on the grounds of the things you don't understand.
adjfkldjfkljdklfj,
Rachel Leigh
Wednesday, March 21, 2012
On Politics and Philosophy and Why My Brain Hurts for Three Hours Twice a Week
I don't really understand why people seem so quick to distinguish politics and philosophy. This might be because one is my major and one is my minor (and every Tuesday and Thursday, I have two back to back classes in those disciplines), but bear with me for a moment. While I'm hesitant to draw distinct lines between any two disciplines, I feel like this instance in particular is a mistake. To make a political decision is to make an inherently moral judgement (I use moral here to mean "related to morality" rather than "good") about the relative worth of the individual or the collective and how we ought to behave with respect to them.
I know some people want to respond that they can come to their decisions about politics or how to act without doing something as "lofty" or "useless" as philosophizing, but that's really not entirely true. You may not throw around heavy philosophical terms like "utilitarianism," "egoism," "deontology," or "Capital T Truths," but you're unknowingly following them in some capacity. If you're weighing the relative harms and benefits of a solution with respect to others, you're thinking like a utilitarian. If you're acting in accordance with the ethical rules you were taught/absorbed from your parents and mentors, you're a virtue ethicist. All philosophy asks of you is to really consider the implications of how you make those choices -- which is exactly what you have to do in politics. Different ethical systems of views of human nature lend themselves to different ideas on laws, the structure of government, and the rights of individuals. The sheer concept of "human rights" is a philosophical speculation.
I think I admire the classical thinkers (and even many moderns) for the fact that they really didn't differentiate the importance of disciplines -- being a philosopher meant living a life where you really thought about things, ranging from who we are and how we should live to physics, math, how we communicate, languages, and yes, even politics.
There's a reason that Plato and Aristotle and Locke and Hobbes and Kant can be applied to ethics and metaphysics and politics as well, and it's because trying to distinguish their ethical ideas from their ideas about those implications for politics and how we should view people would be a mistake. And one I think it's a shame to make.
Thinking,
Rachel Leigh
I know some people want to respond that they can come to their decisions about politics or how to act without doing something as "lofty" or "useless" as philosophizing, but that's really not entirely true. You may not throw around heavy philosophical terms like "utilitarianism," "egoism," "deontology," or "Capital T Truths," but you're unknowingly following them in some capacity. If you're weighing the relative harms and benefits of a solution with respect to others, you're thinking like a utilitarian. If you're acting in accordance with the ethical rules you were taught/absorbed from your parents and mentors, you're a virtue ethicist. All philosophy asks of you is to really consider the implications of how you make those choices -- which is exactly what you have to do in politics. Different ethical systems of views of human nature lend themselves to different ideas on laws, the structure of government, and the rights of individuals. The sheer concept of "human rights" is a philosophical speculation.
I think I admire the classical thinkers (and even many moderns) for the fact that they really didn't differentiate the importance of disciplines -- being a philosopher meant living a life where you really thought about things, ranging from who we are and how we should live to physics, math, how we communicate, languages, and yes, even politics.
There's a reason that Plato and Aristotle and Locke and Hobbes and Kant can be applied to ethics and metaphysics and politics as well, and it's because trying to distinguish their ethical ideas from their ideas about those implications for politics and how we should view people would be a mistake. And one I think it's a shame to make.
Thinking,
Rachel Leigh
Monday, March 5, 2012
On NEDA Week
This past week was Eating Disorder Awareness Week, and
Active Minds (which I have definitely talked about before) as a national
organization supported NEDA’s mission to raise awareness of the prevalence of,
and health risks associated with, eating disorders. This led to an interesting dialogue with one
of my friends, whose first reaction (well, second, after he offered to buy me
curly fries) was that he was tired of everyone saying that society is the
problem.
(image credit: National Eating Disorders
Association, 2009)
I mean, don’t get me wrong, society’s image of what people
should look like is really screwed up.
The media does put up these generally-unattainable, Photoshop-happy
photos and images of girls with waists the size of pill bottles and men with muscles
larger than their heads. And, fun fact,
because these images are disseminated into society, these highly unrealistic
expectations of normality become
what people perceive as “normal.” And,
for the love of god, do not get me started on Barbie unless you want the same
regurgitated list of fun facts about what a little girl’s first toy does to her
sense of body image.
And yeah, the media’s presentation of body image has a lot
to do with the development of eating disorders.
But it’s not like we deal with it exactly right either. Because then the first response is always
“you’re perfect just the way you are,” which is absolutely true for a lot of
people. But the United States IS facing
an obesity epidemic, and that’s not healthy, either. Obesity leads to diabetes, heart disease,
cancer, and a whole other host of serious medical problems, and that’s not
good.
The problem is that in both cases, the focus is on image and
not health. There are healthy and safe
ways to lose weight, get in shape, build muscle mass, etc. But the emphasis on the one hand is that
those ways won’t have the same drastic change to your image that disordered
eating or over-exercising will. But on
the other hand, emphasizing that everyone is perfect is again about an
image. All bodies are beautiful, I will
absolutely agree – the human body is an amazing and beautiful thing, regardless
of its size or shape. But beauty and
perfection aren’t the same thing. But if
you’re trying to change things about it, it should be because you want to be
healthy, not because you want to look different.
A healthy mindset is all about loving your body because it’s
YOUR body and it’s an absolute miracle regardless of how it looks…but loving
your body means taking care of it, staying in shape, treating it right, and
giving it what it needs. I’m all for
self-improvement, but only if it’s healthy.
Yours (with thighs that touch),
Rachel Leigh
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)